Mainers describe cost of CMP monopoly: ‘I ended up having to file for bankruptcy’

Electricity ratepayers gathered at the University of Southern Maine in Portland Tuesday to denounce what they termed a lack of accountability and mismanagement plaguing Central Maine Power, which they said ultimately hurts Maine energy consumers.

At a press conference organized by the Maine Small Business Coalition (MSBC) and other affected groups, CMP customers shared stories of erratic and often massive energy bills. The press conference took place before a public hearing being held on the campus to consider CMP’s proposed rate increase.

“Two winters ago, I was already going through a rough patch. A divorce and child support payments were taking a financial toll and I started to get into debt,” said Rob DuPaul, a contractor from Sanford who is among the more than 4,000 small business owners that make up MSBC. “And then my electricity bill started to skyrocket.”

After CMP had replaced his electricity meter in 2017, DuPaul watched as his electricity bills shot up from $100 one month to $400 the next month, with some as high as $1,500 without any change in his electricity use.

Rob DuPaul speaking at the press conference. Even after declaring bankruptcy, DuPaul still owes CMP $4,000. | Cara DeRose

“I used the small amount of savings I had left to update my electrical appliances -— refrigerator, oven, stove, air conditioner, hot water heater, washer and dryer, lighting – with new energy-efficient models, all with the hope of lowering my CMP bill,” he continued. “However, nothing worked.”

After calling CMP produced no results, DuPaul and his fiancée, Elizabeth, decided to sell their house to pay off their debt and avoid bankruptcy. But the $1500 a month electricity bills scared off potential buyers.

“No one wanted to pay more for electricity than they would for a mortgage,” DuPaul said. “I ended up having to file for bankruptcy.”

CMP has come under fire for erroneous billing practices, often dramatically overcharging low-income Mainers already disproportionately burdened by high energy bills. DuPaul, Rep. Seth Berry (D-Bowdoinham), former Maine Public Advocate Gordon Weil, and others called for the Public Utilities Commission to strip CMP’s status that has allowed it to be the sole power provider for a large portion of the state and protect consumers from additional rate increases.

“CMP has failed it customers, but it seeks a rate increase,” said Weil. “That’s downright suicidal.”

Berry recounted several stories from his constituents, including that of a woman raising her granddaughter who has to choose between food, medicine, or paying her utility bills every month.

“[We] are here to request politely that the [Public Utilities Commission] use its authority to revoke the monopoly franchise it has afforded to Central Maine Power,” he said. “Central Maine Power has demonstrated repeatedly that it is no longer fit to hold that monopoly franchise.”

“We wouldn’t be here today if CMP owned up to its wrongdoings and stopped putting the blame on their customers,” said Lauren Loomis, co-founder of CMP Ratepayers United, which is made up of ratepayers, labor and business leaders, community organizations and other legislators.

This month, Gov. Janet Mills signed into law a bill  that requires the Maine Public Utilities Commission to study whether or not replacing Central Maine Power and Emera with a consumer-owned utility is feasible for the state. The proposal to create a statewide model called the Maine Power Delivery Authority, put forth by Berry, was tabled for next session. It is likely to face significant opposition from CMP and industry lobbyists.

Top photo: Maine’s first Public Advocate Gordon Weil calling on the Public Utilities Commission to break up Central Maine Power. (Photo by Maine Small Business Coalition)

About Cara DeRose

Avatar photoCara DeRose is a staff writer for Beacon. A graduate of the University of Southern Maine, she served as writer and copy editor for the USM Free Press and interned at the Portland Press Herald.

Sign up for Beacon newsletters

Our newsletter, sent each evening, curates the day's most important stories from newsrooms around Maine.

Get the Daily News Sweep