Opinion: New tax relief plan will disproportionately benefit wealthy seniors

This year, lawmakers included a tax change in the state’s budget that will significantly expand tax benefits for pension recipients in Maine. Beginning in 2023, pension recipients will be allowed to exempt up to $25,000 in pension income from state income taxes, and that amount will increase to $35,000 for tax years 2025 and after. Although efforts to improve economic security of older Mainers should be a priority issue for lawmakers, this policy fails to meet the mark as the benefits are heavily weighted to help wealthy households and the policy comes at a tremendous cost to state resources. Further efforts to expand this exemption beyond what the legislature has already improved would benefit an even wealthier cohort of Mainers and come at even greater cost to revenues.

Maine already offered significant income tax benefits to older Mainers including:

  • No income tax on social security income
  • A large standard deduction and personal exemption that exempts the first $17,400 of taxable income for single filers and $34,800 for married filers
  • A $10,000 pension exemption on all pensions, 401(k)s, and IRAs which is reduced for every dollar of social security income — meaning a person with $5,000 in social security income would be allowed to exempt $5,000 in other retirement income from taxes
  • A larger property tax fairness credit for Mainers age 65 and older that offsets high property tax costs for homeowners and renters with low incomes with an income tax refund

A single Mainer with $20,000 in social security income and $15,000 in pension income would owe no income tax in Maine under the previous tax structure; their social security income would be untaxed and $15,000 in pension income zeroed out by their standard deduction and personal exemption.

Increasing the pension exemption up to $35,000 does little for older Mainers with low income who are generally already exempt from the income tax because of benefits already in place. No households in the bottom 20 percent of households by income and only 5 percent of households in the second 20 percent of households see any tax cut from this change (see Table 1). The higher exemption amount largely benefits older Mainers with high incomes — who still had taxable income after all the other tax benefits were considered — although the benefits taper off slightly for the top 1 percent of households who are most likely to have high social security incomes that offset their allowable pension exemption. According to analysis from the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, the new policy will cost $85 million annually once fully phased in. Of that, $53 million would benefit households with incomes over $114,000 which are in the top fifth of households by income.

One group that will and should benefit from this change is public service retirees who paid into a state pension plan instead of social security during their time of service. The entire retirement income of lifelong public servants including teachers, transportation workers, and other state employees might be made up of public pension income and these individuals may have no social security income at all. But in Maine, public pension income does not receive the same tax exempt status as social security income. The legislature considered bills such as LD 1227 that would have specifically addressed this issue and cost considerably less but ultimately chose the much broader expansion to pension exemptions.

Even though this change was recently enacted, some people are calling for all pension income to receive tax free status. Maine Center for Economic Policy strongly opposes pursuing this policy, as the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy estimates it would cost an additional $175 million each year and deliver nearly all benefits to the wealthiest households who can most afford to pay taxes, while doing nothing to benefit older Mainers with low income. The wealthiest 20 percent of households would receive 93 percent of the $175 million cost annually.

Maine has an income tax to fund essentials like schools, affordable health care, and infrastructure. The income tax is the only broad-based state and local tax that taxes residents based on ability to pay, as property and sales taxes disproportionately ask more from households with lower income. Exempting pension income from income taxation cuts huge holes into the tax code that undermine our ability to fund our shared priorities fairly and come at a great cost to the resources we have available to invest in our collective wellbeing.

Top photo: Pictures of Money, Creative Commons via Flickr

About Sarah Austin

Avatar photoSarah is a policy analyst for the Maine Center for Economic Policy. She holds a master’s of public affairs from the University of Wisconsin-Madison’s La Follette School of Public Affairs and a bachelor’s of science in environmental policy from Maine’s Unity College. Prior to MECEP, she worked at the State Innovation Exchange at the Center on Wisconsin Strategy and on issue campaigns in Maine and across the country on issues ranging from tax reform to non-discrimination.

Sign up for Beacon newsletters

Our newsletter, sent each evening, curates the day's most important stories from newsrooms around Maine.